Average customer rating:
|
Evolution of the Social Contract
Brian Skyrms Manufacturer: Cambridge University Press ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback Similar Items:
ASIN: 0521555833 |
Book Description
In this highly readable book, Brian Skyrms, a recognized authority on game and decision theory, investigates traditional problems of the social contract in terms of evolutionary dynamics. Game theory is skillfully employed to offer new interpretations of a wide variety of social phenomena, including justice, mutual aid, commitment, convention and meaning. The book is not technical and requires no special background knowledge. As such, it could be enjoyed by students and professionals in a wide range of disciplines: political science, philosophy, decision theory, economics and biology.Customer Reviews:
Subtle and surprisingly casual- a really entertaining book........1998-03-30
I think the final chapter is one of the most compelling explanations available in print of how differential reproduction can and does most frequently create environments where individuals of a species engage in activities that benefit the group at their own personal expense. He leads directly to the point of any given chapter without beating you over the head with it and by the time you get there, you realize that it was without resorting to extensive technical language or drawing on a huge number of oblique studies. It probably doesn't need to be said that this book doesn't provide much to the "rational choice social contract" thinkers and I think the title is more than enough to steer them away, anyway.
In summary, I think this book would be of tremendous interest to anyone interested in Game theory, Theoretical mathematics, sociology, political science, microeconomics or any of a number of different fields specifically because of the author's aversion to distilling the ideas presented in the book into a misleading one sentence conclusion. If you're looking for a brief yet salient discussion of the subject matter, this is both.
Average customer rating:
|
Game Theory and the Social Contract, Vol. 2: Just Playing (Economic Learning and Social Evolution)
Ken Binmore Manufacturer: The MIT Press ProductGroup: Book Binding: Hardcover Similar Items:
ASIN: 0262024446 |
Book Description
In Volume 1 of Game Theory and the Social Contract, Ken Binmore restated the problems of moral and political philosophy in the language of game theory. In Volume 2, Just Playing, he unveils his own controversial theory, which abandons the metaphysics of Immanuel Kant for the naturalistic approach to morality of David Hume. According to this viewpoint, a fairness norm is a convention that evolved to coordinate behavior on an equilibrium of a society's Game of Life. This approach allows Binmore to mount an evolutionary defense of Rawls's original position that escapes the utilitarian conclusions that follow when orthodox reasoning is applied with the traditional assumptions. Using ideas borrowed from the theory of bargaining and repeated games, Binmore is led instead to a form of egalitarianism that vindicates the intuitions that led Rawls to write his Theory of Justice.Customer Reviews:
Important Contribution to Political Philosophy.......2001-02-13
Binmore thus offers us a "coevolution of genes and culture" in which the acceptance of original position moral arguments is written into our genes, but the cultural content depends on local environmental conditions and random variation. Again drawing on the ethnographic literature, Binmore focuses on food sharing as the most important rule of justice to be decided by a foraging group. In foraging societies, high variance foodstuffs such as meat are equally shared, irrespective of who made the kill. Equal sharing is thus a moral rule justified by reasoning from the original position of hunters who do not know exactly which among them will be lucky or skilled.
Binmore uses evolutionary game theory to analyze social interactions. This adds a welcome degree of clarity to ethical reasoning. Indeed, Binmore is quite clear that all of his substantive results depend on the plausibility of the game theoretic models he presents and analyzes.
While fairness norms are biologically determined for Binmore, the players in Binmore's games are rational self-interested agents. Thus all of the results of two-person game theory based on the rational actor model can be deployed in analyzing social justice. It follows in particular that "[i]n a well-ordered society, each citizen honors the social contract because it is in his own self-interest to do so, provided that enough of his fellow citizens do the same." (5) There is no sense in which moral behavior is opposed to self-interested behavior. Moreover, since players do not behave ethically in bargaining, there is no sense in which the institutions resulting from their bargaining have any abstract normative standing. "Evolutionists simply seek to understand," says Binmore, "why some types of human organization survive better than others.... evolutionary ethics offers no authority whatsoever to those who wish to claim that some moral systems are somehow intrinsically superior to others.' (179)
Different societies can thus embrace different institutions because comparisons in the original position depend on `empathetic preferences' that are culturally specific. It is in part for this reason that Binmore calls himself a `whig,' by which he means a moderate progressive, not seduced by the grand visions of a totally alternative society as proposed by the Left and the Right. The latter two, he claims, make social judgments in a universal, ahistorical manner that have nothing to do with the actual fairness processes in real societies.
Just Playing is an important and welcome contribution to the literature. The book does, however, have some faults. The most salient is that crucial analytical material and discursive asides jumbled together. One must read the whole book, and make numerous references back and forth, to understand the basic argument. Moreover, the book is intended for a general audience interested in political philosophy, yet even professional economists will find the analytical parts difficult to follow.
Another problem is that Binmore uses evolutionary game theory where it suits him, but abandons it when it does not. For instance, while Binmore uses naturalism to justify the assertion that Homo sapiens is genetically programed to accept the original position, but he gives no empirical evidence that this is in fact the case. Moreover, it is implausible that evolution imprinted us with an original position orientation, but in no other way affected our moral behavior, so that the assumption of Homo economicus remains valid for bargaining purposes. Laboratory experiments reveal forms of prosocial behavior (e.g., rejecting `unfair' offers in an ultimatum game, or punishing free riders in a public goods game) that relate directly to questions of justice and fairness, yet contradict the Homo economicus model. The notion that human sociality can be explained by `enlightened self-interest,' even when accompanied by respect for the original position, will not likely survive a close study of the evidence (See my book Game Theory Evolving, Princeton University Press, 2000).
Upgrading Rawls' "Theory of Justice".......2000-06-24
Average customer rating:
|
The Sex Contract: The Evolution of Human Behavior
Helen E. Fisher Manufacturer: William Morrow & Co ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback Similar Items:
ASIN: 0688015999 |
Customer Reviews:
Powerful concept.......2005-08-03
The origin of our behavior.......1998-06-21
Average customer rating:
|
The social contract: A personal inquiry into the evolutionary sources of order and disorder
Robert Ardrey Manufacturer: Dell Pub. Co ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback ASIN: B0006WIOQE |
Customer Reviews:
Robert Ardrey's views remain valid today.......2005-09-21
Thought provoking and informative.......2005-08-07
hard read.......2003-04-29
One of my 5 top books.......2001-05-24
man's behav.determin.by instinctive soc.con. for survival.......1999-04-09
Average customer rating: |
Social Institutions of Capitalism: Evolution and Design of Social Contracts
Manufacturer: Edward Elgar Publishing ProductGroup: Book Binding: Hardcover ASIN: 1843764954 |
Book Description
Offering a diverse set of contributions to current social contracting research, The Social Institutions of Capitalism illustrates how social contracts necessarily underlie and facilitate all forms of capitalist production and exchange.The editors bring together novel contributions from fields as diverse as economics, evolutionary game theory, contract law, business ethics, moral philosophy and anthropology to offer multifaceted but subtly intertwined perspectives on fundamental questions concerning human cooperation.
This interdisciplinary book, with articles written by academics who are widely known and respected in their fields, will be of great value to those interested in political theory, moral philosophy and business ethics.
Average customer rating: |
Cultural evolution and constitutional public choice: Institutional diversity and economic performance on American Indian reservations (Working paper series ... John F. Kennedy School of Government)
Stephen E Cornell Manufacturer: Malcolm Wiener Center for Social Policy, John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University ProductGroup: Book Binding: Unknown Binding ASIN: B0006QDQ2C |
Average customer rating: |
The design of rural development: Proposals for the evolution of a social contract suited to conditions in Southern Africa (Saldru working paper)
Norman Reynolds Manufacturer: Southern Africa Labour and Development Research Unit ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback ASIN: 079920434X |
Average customer rating: |
Evolution and utilitarianism: Social contract III (CREST working paper)
Ken Binmore Manufacturer: Dept. of Economics, University of Michigan ProductGroup: Book Binding: Unknown Binding ASIN: B00071ONSW |
Average customer rating: |
On law and lawlessism
Sean Sheeter Manufacturer: Process Press ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback ASIN: 0960537856 |
Average customer rating:
|
The World According To Pimm: A Scientist Audits the Earth
Stuart Pimm Manufacturer: McGraw-Hill ProductGroup: Book Binding: Hardcover Similar Items:
ASIN: 0071374906 |
Book Description
Ever since the publication of Rachel Carson's Silent Spring in the '60s, we've known that human activity has had detrimental effects on the environment. Yet after four decades of growing awareness of environmental problems, we still see passionate disagreement between activists and business interests over what should be done. Much of the impasse stems from the fact that the problems are difficult to quantify. How do we assess the impact of habitat loss on species, when we haven't even counted them all, and we are just beginning to understand how they interact? How do we determine how great a population the ecosystem can bear, when we have yet to quantify the depletion of resources? How do we know if current extinction rates are excessive if we don't know what "normal" extinction rates are? Without scientific, numerical information we cannot make headway on these issues. Working on the front lines of conservation biology since the early '70s, Stuart Pimm is one of the pioneers whose work has put the "science" in environmental science. His research covers the reasons why species become extinct, how fast they do so, the global patterns of habitat loss and species extinction, the role of introduced species in causing extinction and, importantly, the management consequences of this research. In The World According to Pimm, he leads us on a tour of the world and shows us how science can take us deeper into these issues. We see how humans impact has affected Hawaii since its first colonization by the Polynesians; how centuries of persistent agriculture have affected drylands; how forests have feared and how they are likely to fare in the near future; how future population pressures will affect our freshwater supply, of which we already use 50%. We journey across the oceans and discover where their resources lie, and we take a look inside the endangered species ledger, which conservationists are reluctantly filling with "EX"ex, for extinct. Though he never preaches or scolds, Pimm is keeping careful accounts, with hard numbers, of what we are taking from the earth. He is also wonderfully descriptive, full of appreciation for the riches of the planet and the excitement that increasing scientific knowledge always brings, but also urgently hopeful that our growing understanding of our world will enable us to save it.Customer Reviews:
Insight from Numbers guides Strategy.......2006-12-01
Very useful for courses on environmental ethics.......2003-11-23
Great title wrong book.......2003-11-12
Are we the planet's cancer?.......2002-09-02
There are approximately 130 million square kilometers of land surface producing an average of about 1,000 tons of biomass a year. Of this 130 billion tons we use 42% (60 billion tons) for food, grazing, wood for building and burning, etc. Pimm's comment is "Man eats Planet! Two-Fifths Already Gone!" (Chapter 6).
Professor Pimm also audits the ocean and gives us similar bottom-line figures. He explains how he gets the information, how he collates it and how his various sources agree and don't agree. He is in the field and on the ocean, floating down Amazon rivers and flying over the African veldt. He recalls the land before industrialization and tells us how it has changed. He tells the story of the great American westward expansion and what that expansion did to the forests and the prairies. He recalls the tragedy of Easter Island. Pimm writes in a witty and fascinating style that makes the dry numbers come alive and sparkle like fish in incandescent water. One gets the sense in reading him that here is somebody who knows what he is talking about, somebody who has worked hard to understand how the planet's various systems work, and what is happening to them because of human consumption and waste. His tone is balanced and calm and conversational. He appears to have no axes to grind, no favorites to play. Although he claims in the Prologue that his book is "unashamedly optimistic" (p. 8), the implications of the numbers he presents are nonetheless alarming.
For example, Pimm reports that our population has nearly doubled since 1970 but the amount of cropland has only increased from 14 million square kilometers to 15. He notes that "Agriculture feeds far more people from almost the same area of land." He adds, "In this statistic, eternally optimistic Panglossians see continuing progress that allows us to push the envelope of our environmental constraints. In the same statistic, worried Cassandras notice the constraints on the area of croplands that prevent it from expanding with our growing population." (p. 106)
He notes that virtually all of the best cropland is already being used, but not necessarily for cultivation. A significant percentage is under the concrete and asphalt of our cities. Furthermore the drier lands in places like California's central valleys, the soils are quickly becoming salinized by irrigation so that they yield less and less per acre. In some place the salt content from irrigation of the soil is too high for food plants to grow. All over the world this problem exists and as Pimm notes there is no solution in sight. The croplands that benefit from rainwater, that is, water that is distilled by the water cycle, do not turn salty, but the amount of that land is strictly limited and shrinking because of urban sprawl.
Pimm uses a party metaphor to highlight the situation. Some guests he says pick out the cashews from the bowl of mixed nuts. "Not for them the lowly sunflower seeds, still in their husks...The high-graders who...[got the cashews] are now demanding the even more expensive Macadamia nuts. The doorbell is ringing, announcing the arrival of more guests..." (p. 107)
Pimm also looks at the fisheries and what affect our fishing has on them. His conclusion: "Humanity does not use all of the oceans' production, but what we do use is already enough to damage the oceans, seriously and perhaps permanently. (p. 127) He also notes that without government subsidies, in places like Canada, Russia, the US, Japan and Europe, fishing on a large scale would be impossible because it no longer pays. In Johannesburg where there is a world wide conference on ecology taking place as I write this, one of the main topics is how farm and fishing subsidies in first world countries are keeping the farmers and fishermen in third world countries poor. Food prices are kept artificially low so that African and Asian farmers cannot compete in the marketplace. That is one (unintended, one would hope) consequence of subsidies, but another is that the intense use of land and sea are rapidly reducing the yields, in some cases to the point of no return.
The land and the ocean are the first two parts of the book. In part three, on biodiversity, Pimm sheds some light on taxonomy and how difficult it is to count species. In an Epilogue, he addresses solutions and his hope for the future. Pimm is optimistic. I wish I could be. But until we feel the pain of lost resources, and actually have to give up some of our comfort, I don't think anything substantial is going to be done toward the avowed goal of sustained growth. (Actually, I think "sustained growth" may be an oxymoron dreamed up by some transnational corporations to excuse their continued pillaging of the planet's resources.) At any rate, humans act out of necessity. By the time the real necessity kicks in for most of the first world, much of the planet's resources will be gone.
The good news though, according to Pimm, is that most of those resources are renewable. The forests of the Eastern US have largely returned (without much of their animal wildlife or flora diversity, I must point out) and while the wild salmon may go the way of the dodo, there will be farm salmon, and if we lose the swordfish, there will still be tuna, etc.
This is an important book that anyone concerned about the future of our planet should not miss. It is in a sense fundamental to an understanding of the most important issues facing us today.
The World According To Pimm Review.......2001-12-11
Average customer rating: |
A Scientist Audits the Earth
Stuart L. Pimm Manufacturer: Rutgers University Press ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback Similar Items:
ASIN: 0813535409 |
Book Description
Praise for hardcover edition (as The World According to Pimm)"Among ecologists who can apply their understanding of basic science to the modern human predicament, Stuart Pimm is one of the very best in the world today. He writes clearly, interestingly, and understandably. This book will interest literally everyone!"Jared Diamond, author of Guns, Germs, and Steel
"A dazzling tour d'horizon of the twenty-first century environment. The author informs us of the approaching fate of the natural world (including our own species) with uncommon scientific authority, style, and wit."Edward O. Wilson, University Research Professor, Harvard University
"This book explains environmental issues numerically to answer questions of whether humans will be better off in the next century . . .. Recommended."Library Journal
Humans use 50 percent of the world's freshwater supply and consume 42 percent of its plant growth. We are liquidating animals and plants one hundred times faster than the natural rate of extinction. Such numbers should make it clear that our impact on the planet has been, and continues to be, extreme and detrimental. Yet even after decades of awareness of our environmental peril, there remains passionate disagreement over what the problems are and how they should be remedied.
Much of the impasse stems from the fact that the problems are difficult to quantify. How do we assess the impact of habitat loss on various species, when we haven't even counted them all? And just what factors go into that 42 percent of biomass we are hungrily consuming? It is only through an understanding of the numbers that we will be able to break that impasse and come to agreement on which environmental issues are most critical and how they might best be addressed.
Working on the front lines of conservation biology, Stuart Pimm is one of the pioneers whose work has put the "science" in environmental science. In this book, he appoints himself "investment banker of the global, biological accounts," checking the environmental statistics gathered by tireless scientists in work that is always painstaking and often heartbreaking. With wit, passion, and candor, he reveals the importance of understanding where these numbers come from and what they mean. To do so, he takes the reader on a globe-circling tour of our beautiful, but weary, planet from the volcanic mountains and rainforests of Hawai'i to the boreal forests of Siberia.
At times, the view looks rather grim. Yet Pimm, ever the optimist, presents a world filled with mysterious beauty, the infinite variety of nature, and an urgent hope that through an understanding of our planet's environmental past and present, we will be inspired to save it from future extinction.
Average customer rating: |
Pimm's Audit. (Topical Reviews).: An article from: American Scientist
Manufacturer: Sigma Xi, The Scientific Research Society ProductGroup: Book Binding: Digital ASIN: B0008ESJM4 Release Date: 2005-07-29 |
Average customer rating: |
The World According To Pimm: A Scientist Audits the Earth
Stuart L. Pimm Manufacturer: McGraw-Hill ProductGroup: Book Binding: Paperback ASIN: B000OFZJAM |
Books:
Recommended Books