Brooklyn Dreams

Customer Reviews:

dreamlike.......2003-09-04

"Can a book change your life? I don't know. But it can certainly take the unvoiced, inarticulate changes of the soul, put them into words and reflect them back at you-in brilliant, devastating ways." These words are not mine, but rather those of Vincent Carl Santini, main character of Brooklyn Dreams. In this passage he's discussing having read Dostoyevsky, but I find them very fitting words with which to introduce the novel itself.

Brooklyn Dreams is Santini's story; he narrates the events of his life as he reflects backwards on his senior year of high school, 1970-1971. Part Stand by Me, part Basketball Diaries, the tale utilizes the physical setting (Brooklyn, of course) and the drug culture of the time period as a backdrop for personal exploration. It is no coincidence that the main character is named Vincent but is called Carl in parts of the story, for this is really about Santini's search for himself, trying to pin down his identity. At the same time, he is trying to find the missing piece to the puzzle, the answers to the big questions in regards to love, family, death and the nature of God.

Brooklyn Dreams was an experiment when it was first released. Back in 1994 DC was just beginning to get its Paradox imprint off the ground. In those early days, Vertigo was still a place where you ran into superheroes on occasion, albeit heroes on the edge, and DC felt they needed to have a place where they could publish works completely outside of their universe, works that were for mature readers. I don't mean mature in the sense of violence and T&A but instead thought-provoking and meaningful. Paradox was that mature place, and Brooklyn Dreams was their flagship book.

Eventually the line failed, just shortly after the release of the now-famous Road to Perdition, but of all the works they released in their short time of publication, Brooklyn Dreams is the stand-out. Similar to Road to Perdition, it emulated manga in its design, being published in digest size and complete black and white. However, unlike that work, Brooklyn Dreams was released in four parts; each part had ninety-six pages and sold for 4.95 a piece. Just collected together in one volume and re-released for the first time back in mid-April, the book will now cost you 12.95, a considerable amount less than it would have almost ten years ago.

The writer of this graphic novel, J.M. DeMatteis, is a bit of a cipher. He is regularly known for writing titles in a vein that is a bit out there. His most recent works include the most recent Spectre series and the Seth Fisher-illustrated one-shot Green Lantern: Willworld, but he has also written some fairly standard superhero fare for Marvel with Spiderman and Captain America. He has written Moonshadow, Seekers into the Mystery and various other Vertigo titles, while at the same time he worked as co-writer with Keith Giffen of the madcap Justice League of the late '80s.

Obviously the versatility of DeMatteis is not in question, but had it been, Brooklyn Dreams would have solidified his reputation as a man capable of holding his own in any genre. Here he casts aside the conventions of fantasy and the superhero to set his story in a place that is at times much more absurd-the real world. The novel is populated with characters so real that you cannot believe they're complete fictions. It has a style that is so real you believe it must be thinly veiled autobiography, even if it's not. And I have no doubt that it isn't, that the author's life was nothing like the main character's. But the skill with which he weaves this tale makes you believe this was his life.

Honestly he at times even makes you believe it was YOUR life, that he's somehow telling your story. The work draws you in so much by fully painting a rounded picture of its setting that you feel as if you lived in Brooklyn circa the early 1970s, even if you're really from a small town in southern Illinois. And the characters react to one another in such a way that their emotional issues seem to reflect your own

Admittedly, the narrative itself is meandering and sometimes elusive. As I mentioned, the main character narrates his own story, and Santini has a tendency to ramble. He will sometimes interrupt his own story to go off on a tangent, even going so far as to tell asides within asides. But this is a story that the narrator admits is comprised of imperfect memories, so digressions seem only natural. Plus these departures allow him to take the long way towards his destination, and much of this book's beauty is in that journey, in the small character bits we might not get in other works that are more focused on a goal.

The book too leaves many questions unanswered, as characters who seemed important in the beginning float into the background and are gone. For example, in the final section of the novel, the Santini family seems to almost completely fade away. But in that way it IS like life, how in our youth the influences on us are constantly changing, how you grow apart from family, from your best friend, from yourself even.

By the end, despite some clunkiness in regards to the plot, Brooklyn Dreams will win you over through the atmosphere of sincerity it creates and the sheer humanity of the characters who populate its world. Be it fiction or fact, this story is one of truth, and of the search for truth we all go through as we grow up.

A masterpiece of humor, spirit & autobiography!.......2003-06-05

J. M. DeMatteis' wonderful series about being a confused, angry, yearning teenager in the late 60s is finally available in one volume, and it's long overdue! Anyone who came of age in those years will recognize the emotions & situations, sometimes all too closely & accurately for comfort. And if it did nothing more than recall those times, as it does in such perfect & incisive detail, the story would be a thorough success.

But as the narrator reminds us, "This is a story about God."

The voice of an adult Carl Vincent (or Vincent Carl) Santini -- don't worry, that's all explained -- provides the running commentary as we observe & enter into the troubled, searching life of our young protagonist, struggling to express himself, struggling to understand himself & the Universe, searching for Something long before he's consciously aware of it.

DeMatteis' prose is deceptively casual & easy-going, drawing the reader in as a confidante, but it's also insightful & honest. He cares passionately about the story he's sharing with us & that passion comes through. At the same time, his sense of humor prevents his story from ever becoming pretentious.

The powerful artwork of Glenn Barr brings this story to vivid life, changing to suit the tones of the story, ranging from cartoony to photo-realistic, often in the same panel. You'll pause & linger over many a page for the illustrations as much as for the words.

Book Description

Brooklyn: A Journey Through the City of Dreams explores the streets, neighborhoods, and legends of the most beguilingly diverse urban area in America. The icons of Brooklyn are celebrated-the indomitable Dodgers, legendary Coney Island, and the majestic Brooklyn Bridge-along with other treasures of Brooklyn, in an engaging and unexpected journey through Brooklyn past and present, real and imagined.

Brooklyn is where Walt Whitman wrote Leaves of Grass, Al Capone acquired his famous moniker "Scarface," and Barbra Streisand worked as an usher at the Loews' Kings movie palace. From Coney Island to Flatbush Avenue and from Brooklyn Heights to Prospect Park, Brooklyn: A Journey Through the City of Dreams celebrates the spirit, people, and places that have made Brooklyn a cultural icon.

Customer Reviews:

Francis Morrone Does it Again!.......2005-08-24

What a beautiful book -- for your coffee table or your nightstand. It will make you proud to live in Brooklyn, if you do already (I do!), and it will make you want to visit if you don't. Francis Morrone is, to my view, our city's best architectural historian, and here he also brings his incredible knowledge of food, baseball, and just plain fun to bear on the city's most delightful borough.

A book for anyone who cares about the beauty and majesty of New York City.

Buy anything from this author.......2004-09-04

While this is not a review of the book, it is a review of the author. I took a class from Francis Morrone at NYU and was captivated every day by his breadth of knowledge, his ability to either synthesize or extrapolate at will and, best of all, his ability to convey his undying love for the greatest city in the world. I could wander through NYC with this guy for a month and never tire of the stories he could tell. I don't live in NY right now, but every day I wake up missing the sights and sounds of the city, and that is in no small part due to what I learned from Francis. He is a cultural treasure. Take his class; walk on his tours; and buy his book. I'm online to do just that right now. Oh, and I'm pretty sure Brooklyn is his favorite borough, so it's gotta be good!

Average customer rating:

The Perfect "Just One More Story" Before Bed
Great book for city kids
A Childhood Memory

Flying over Brooklyn
Myron Uhlberg
Manufacturer: Peachtree Publishers
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback

Bedtime & Dreaming | Baby-3 | Children's Books | Subjects | Books

Picture Books | Ages 4-8 | Children's Books | Subjects | Books

General | Ages 4-8 | Children's Books | Subjects | Books

General | Literature | Children's Books | Subjects | Books

All 4-for-3 Deals | 4-for-3 Books Store | Stores | Books
Similar Items:

ASIN: 1561452947

Book Description

A magical story of how a young boy's everyday world is transformed into a snow-covered wonderland through the force of a blizzard and the power of a dream A YOUNG BOY trudges through deep snow in a neighborhood park. Suddenly a strong wind grabs his coat and lifts the child up into the air. Soon the boy is soaring high above his strangely silent, snow-covered neighborhood. As he flies over familiar sites--a bridge over a frozen river, a baseball field, and an amusement park--he gains a new perspective on the world around him. The boy's airborne adventure provides a magical--if temporary--escape from the routine of everyday life. In the end the boy returns to the safety of his home and family, but is left wondering: Was it all just a marvelous dream or did it really happen? Author Myron Uhlberg's story is based in part on his own childhood memories of the Great Blizzard of 1947 which blanketed Brooklyn and the surrounding area under several feet of snow. An author's note at the back of the book provides details about the snowstorm and places this fantasy in its historical context. Illustrator Gerald Fitzgerald's two-page, gently softened illustrations beautifully evoke the story's nostalgia and dreamlike quality.

Customer Reviews:

The Perfect "Just One More Story" Before Bed.......2001-08-01

The other night, my three-year-old son couldn't sleep. I took out my daughter's copy of Flying Over Brooklyn and started to read. He was wide-eyed and smiling through the entire adventure and absolutely surprised when we reached the end, "That was a dream?" he asked. "Yes, go to sleep so you can have an adventure too," I replied. "Wow, I would if I could have dreams THAT good!" I am sure that when my children are older they will appreciate the dreamy glimpses of a world far removed from our own (Brooklyn) and the historic significance of a child's recollection of an unusual event, but for now, they simply enjoy sharing the boy's dream-come-true flight over a snow-covered city. Meanwhile, I appreciate the positive spin it gives to the words, "Bed-time!"

Great book for city kids.......2000-03-13

"This is the first childrens book I have seen written for city kids. Every city kid will appeciate this story about flying over the city and seeing the great snow storm. It is truly a child's dream.

A Childhood Memory.......2000-02-25

Mr. Uhlberg's book FLYING OVER BROOKLYN should be required reading for any child who can read, or even before he has that ability. It is a lovely illustrated book that my grandchildren were delighted and fascinated by, especially when I was able to corroborate how the little boy felt. I, too, as a little boy lived through that blizzard in 1946 and that made the grandkids' eyes open wide, I guess with admiration that I had survived the ordeal. Kudos to Mr. Uhlberg. Give us more, sir!

Last Exit to Brooklyn/Requiem for a Dream/The Room

Average customer rating:

Last Exit to Brooklyn/Requiem for a Dream/The Room

Manufacturer: QPB
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback
ASIN: B000EVZCVM

The Brooklyn Cyclones: Hardball Dreams and the New Coney Island

Average customer rating:

Baseball's back........
The Brooklyn Cyclones: Hardball Dreams and the New Coney Isl
Bleeding Dodger Blue
old school bk baseball is back

The Brooklyn Cyclones: Hardball Dreams and the New Coney Island
Ben Osborne
Manufacturer: NYU Press
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Hardcover

General | Baseball | Sports | Subjects | Books

History | Baseball | Sports | Subjects | Books

General | Sports | Subjects | Books

Book Description

View the Table of Contents. Read the Prologue.

"Osborne...actually lives in Brooklyn. This lends both weight and depth to his account of the Cyclones' birth, and a reality, rather than nostalgic sentimentalism, to his Brooklyn."
—Nine

"Osborne pens a highly readable and detailed account of the inaugural season of the Brooklyn Cyclnes minor league baseball team. There is much to like about this book."—VOYA

"Osborne attempts to tell the story of professional baseball's successful return to Brooklyn through the juxtaposing of his personal experience with two main characters."
—Park Slope Paper"A nice little book that gives an inside look at the big-time small-time where just about all games are sold out and the capital of the world looms in the background, but the game's still in the bushes."
—Blue Ridge Business Journal

"An entertaining tale."
—Chicago Sun-Times

"Though the 2001 season for the Cyclones now seems a decade away, under the watchful eye of Osborne, readers grasp it from several angles. The Brooklyn Cyclones is right on the money."
—NYU Press

"A happy-ending story to which all fans of minor league baseball or who live in communities that have lost a treasured franchise can relate."
— Library Journal

"The account of the season's games is handled deftly, and Osborne effectively captures the zeal of Brooklyn baseball fans."
—Publishers Weekly

"Osborne simultaneously captures baseball as a business, as a passion, and as a dream. That's a rare triple play, and it results in a thoroughly satisfying baseball book."
—Booklist

"Why should anyone outside New York care about the return of baseball to Brooklyn? Because of the long sad absence that preceded it."
—Library Journal

"The Brooklyn Cyclones is right on the money in spelling out baseball's decline among urban youth."
—NY Press

"The Dodgers will likely never return to Brooklyn, but The Brooklyn Cyclones makes it possible for the old-time fan to feel passionate again."—Jeff Pearlman, Newsday staff writer and author of The Bad Guys Won: A Season with the 1986 Mets

"Here, thanks to a sparkling lineup of characters, vivid writing, and a veteran scout's eye for detail, a single season comes alive with far more than just wins and losses; with the power, politics, and people dead center in a book as much about hopes and dreams as it is about baseball."—Armen Keteyian, CBS and HBO Sports

"Love Brooklyn or love baseball or love both, you are sure to love Ben Osborne's tale of the birth of the only team ever named after a roller coaster. The perfect off-season read; in season, the book will make you wonder what you are doing reading when you should be down at Keyspan Park, rooting for those Cyclones."—Michael Daly, New York Daily News columnist and author of Under Ground: A Novel

"If there's more fun than attending a Cyclones' game, it's reading Ben Osborne's warm-hearted, historically observant take on Coney Island's new and very old pastime."—Rick Telander, author of Heaven Is a Playground

"In this book, Osborne describes how, when the Cyclones returned to Brooklyn, they nestled their new stadium, Keyspan Park, in a section of the city that once served as a playground for the wealthy." —Ron Kaplan, Foreword Magazine

When professional baseball returned to Brooklyn in 2001, fans were jubilant and the media swarmed. After losing the Brooklyn Dodgers to California 44 years ago, Brooklyn baseball fans could once again claim a team of their own: the Cyclones, a Class A affiliate of the New York Mets.

The Brooklyn Cyclones: Hardball Dreams and the New Coney Island recounts that first season of the Cyclones. From the construction of the incredible Keyspan Park at Coney Island to their improbable successes on the field, Ben Osborne tells the story of the Cyclones' delicate first year of operation. We see the story up close and personal through the eyes of two very different young men. The first is Anthony Otero, who was raised in a Coney Island housing project and loves baseball, but has never seen a game in person until the Cyclones land in his neighborhood. The second is Brett Kay, a young man from California who has never been to New York, until he becomes the catcher for the Brooklyn Cyclones.

From the plans of politicians like Rudy Giuliani and Howard Golden, to the poverty of Coney Island's citizens, The Brooklyn Cyclones reveals the stories behind the headlines to show that the reality of creating a new sports team often involves broken promises and shattered dreams. Osborne includes chapters on the Cyclones' rivalry with the Staten Island Yankees, the Cyclones' chances of capturing the New York-Penn League title, and an epilogue updating Kay's, Otero's, and the Cyclones' progress through the 2003 season.

Ultimately, Ben Osborne shows how, for these two young men, the Brooklyn Cyclones created dreams the same way the Brooklyn Dodgers allowed the boys of Flatbush to dream about one day playing in the Big Leagues.

Customer Reviews:

Baseball's back...............2004-06-22

With Ben Osborne's newest book, The Brooklyn Cyclones, Hardball Dreams and the New Coney Island, baseball is displayed, honored, and celebrated in such a way that my "jones" for a bleacher seat, a dog and a draft has spiraled out of control. This tale of baseball's return to Brooklyn is much more than just an account of the 2001 season of the Mets' Single-A Brooklyn Cyclones. It is a socially in-depth look into baseballs' influence on not only a community (in this place, the Coney Island neighborhood of Brooklyn), and the city of New York at large, but also on two specific individuals. The two featured in this beautifully crafted piece of work are contrasts in background and involvement with the club. The first featured character is catching prospect, Brett Kay. A native Californian, who had never stepped foot in the Big Apple prior, Kay brings a natural energy to the club, as well as a strong bat and solid defensive play behind the plate. As a single-A prospect, Kay like many others in his position, the Cyclones are the first step in his pursuit of his dream of one day playing in the bigs.
The second individual featured is 13-year old Coney Island resident, Anthony Otero Jr. A big fan of the game of baseball, Otero is the leader of a group of Coney teenagers, who in stark contrast to the borough's basketball history, enjoy using the blacktops for hardball instead of roundball. Living just 15 blocks from the site of KeySpan Park (the cyclone's beautiful boardwalk-side stadium), Osborne chronicles Otero's interest in the team, alongside his own aspirations of one day playing pro ball. Possibly the most intriguing portions of the book, are the historical sections which detail Brooklyn's rich baseball tradition with the Dodgers, the economic rise and fall of Coney Island, and finally ex-mayor, Rudy Guilani's attempt to use the genesis of the team as a cornerstone of his "legacy" as mayor.

In the end, this slice of Americana is truly an enjoyable read. A tale which intertwines many different faces of the American sports fan, from the prospect, to the fierce political leader, to the local kid from the projects. How these individuals affect and are ultimately affected by the team is the true story line. A couple years later, Kay puts it perfectly in the book's final thought, "that season in Brooklyn was something that I'll never experience again."

The Brooklyn Cyclones: Hardball Dreams and the New Coney Isl.......2004-04-23

Ben Osborne's second book is a solid journalistic foray that delves into the political, regional, and economic contexts surrounding the return of professional baseball to the borough of Brooklyn 44 years after the Dodgers took off for California. The first season of the minor league Cyclones, an afiliate of the New York Mets, who play in the New York-Penn League, is recounted in detail through the eyes of Anthony Otero, a kid from the projects and Coney Island native who dreams of playing for the Yankees but had never been to a professional game before the Cyclones came to town and Brett Kay, a Californian catching prospect drafted by the Mets and farmed out to the Class A Cyclones to begin his big league career.

From the potitical manuevering of Rudy Giuliani to the construction of the incredible Keyspan Park at Coney Island to the season long sellout crowds Ben Osborne crafts a riviting story and fascinating read that encompasses both historical and cultural perspectives while exploring the media circus that followed the Cyclones in their inaugual season. The book is about more then just baseball. It's about the inner city struggle, big city politics, and hardball dreams. An accurate portrayal and intriguing analysis of the realities facing Brooklyn and Coney Island today.

Bleeding Dodger Blue.......2004-04-16

Great book that brought back a lot of memories of faded Brooklyn Glory. Osborne captures the details of a summer in the minors leagues from the fresh cut grass of a new season to the hope of Major League stardom.

Warning: This book has a tendency to make the reader into a die hard Cyclones fan.

old school bk baseball is back.......2004-04-08

Great book. Loved the historical aspects, and the personal stories of the player and local kid. A great gift for father's day, espcially for anyone with Brooklyn roots or a love of baseball.

Average customer rating:

Bridge of Dreams
Bridge of Dreams

Bridge of Dreams
Burhan Dogancay , and Burhan Doganay
Manufacturer: Hudson Hills Press
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback

General | Architecture | Professional & Technical | Subjects | Books

Architectural | Photography | Arts & Photography | Subjects | Books

Collections, Catalogues & Exhibitions | Photography | Arts & Photography | Subjects | Books

General | Photography | Arts & Photography | Subjects | Books

General | Arts & Photography | Subjects | Books

Book Description

The Brooklyn Bridge is one of the architectural and engineering wonders of the world.

Customer Reviews:

Bridge of Dreams.......2001-09-18

The photographs in this book vividly capture a very unique period of the Brooklyn Bridge as it was being restored in the late 1980's. The use of black and white photography, together with the unusually decorated subject matter, namely the Brooklyn Bridge draped in safety nets, make for a visually stimulating combination.

Bridge of Dreams.......2001-05-05

One of a kind photographs of the Brooklyn Bridge as it has never been seen before, mysteriously draped in safety nets. A a real treat for the eye.

Average customer rating:

Intense and touching poems

Brooklyn dreams
Cari Jaenke
Manufacturer: Heins Publications
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Unknown Binding

Customer Reviews:

Intense and touching poems.......2007-01-26

Reading these poems you can feel the deep emotions of the author... Her pain, her joys, her consiquences in life, her open mind. I've passed it along to many people to read, as there are words to relate to everyone.

Average customer rating:

BROOKLYN DREAMS Vols 1-4
J. M. DeMatteis
Manufacturer: Paradox
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback
ASIN: B000H0WA10

Average customer rating:

Brooklyn Dreams #2: Criminal Behavior
J.M. DeMatteis
Manufacturer: Paradox Press
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Comic
ASIN: B000UL5ZBS

Average customer rating:

Brooklyn Dreams #3: Duality Blues
J.M. DeMatteis
Manufacturer: Paradox Press
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Comic

General | Graphic Novels | Comics & Graphic Novels | Subjects | Books
ASIN: B000UL08EC

Amazon.com

A History of the Synoptic Problem, by David Laird Dungan, is an accessible, academic study of a question that has needled readers of the New Testament since before the Bible was canonized: How does one reconcile the different accounts of Jesus's life given by the four gospels? Today the most highly publicized answer to this question is the one offered by John Dominic Crossan and the Jesus Seminar, who seek to reconcile the differences among the gospels by designating some events and statements in the gospels historically true and others false. There are lots of other ways to explore the synoptic problem, however, and Dungan provides a clear and lively history of the strategies employed by Origen, Augustine, Erasmus, Spinoza, Locke, and others. Dungan's method is to break the synoptic problem down into its corollary questions: Which gospels should be considered in the debate? Which text of each gospel should be considered? And how should one read the Bible in general and the gospels in particular? Dungan's interest in these questions is not merely literary; he also delves into the political and economic agendas that have influenced biblical interpretation. In this regard, the most interesting and original connection he makes is to explain the relationship between the rise of the modern historical-critical method of reading scripture (asking who wrote the books of the Bible, when, how, and for whom) and the creation and maintenance of political democracy--and furthermore, the ways in which fundamentalist "literal" readings of Scripture serve the same goal. Dungan's own investment in debates on the synoptic problem is shot through with an appealing humility about the stakes of the debate. "At its deepest level, the Synoptic Problem is not a scientific 'problem'," he writes. "[T]he quest for the correct solution to the Synoptic Problem, like the Church's quest for the correct canon of the Gospels, and the correct text of the Gospels, and the correct way to interpret the Gospels, is a vital aspect of the Church's perennial quest for the Word of Life." --Michael Joseph Gross

Customer Reviews:

The lay out of the book continually irritated.......2006-04-22

I am more than a little surprised that other reviewers gave this five stars. The general lay out, indentation, bullet points, nu mbering etc was bewildering - there simply was no proper schematic to the book. The book read like a book in progress and in need of a great deal of polish. Nonetheless, Dungan has some vey interesting ideas about the development of modern hermeunetics, namely that in its worst form, it follows the rules of Spinoza whose subtext was the destruction of the Bible as the word of God. And, that fundamnetalists are in truth followers of John Locke' subjectivist philosopy. Its interesting that he considers that catholics scholars such as Raymond Brown have avoided the worst excess of the modern approach. Overall a little disappointing.

Synoptic Problem.......2006-02-27

Excellent history of Synoptic Problem, going right back to biblical times, unlike most similar reviews which only start at about the 18th century.

Copious Historical and Biblical Research.......2003-07-07

I bought this book thinking that it was going to help me harmonize the differences in the Sypotic Gospels (Matthew, Mark, and Luke). I got more than I bargained for!

One fifth of the book (at the back end) are detailed explanatory and resourceful chapter Notes. These Notes contain an abundance of supporting evidence and explanations from antiquity, early church history, Patristic writings, Greek lexicology, and others).

The material of the book is quite dry and the primary audience seems to be biblical scholars. Since I am not a scholar, I had to rely on the back-end Notes a lot to understand the points the author was making in the respective chapters.

Nevertheless, following the three historical approaching to the Synoptic problem presented in the book, I have been fortunate (and blessed as a result) to learn a great deal about the history of the early Church, the development of Bible translations throughout the ages, and current trends in Christianity.

I would recommend this work to anyone seriously interested in Christianity (especially the canon, text, composition, and interpretations of the Gospels).

The best history of the synoptic problem available.......2000-08-18

Dungan does a great job of expanding the conversation of what the components are of the synoptic problem. He is daring, bold, and erudite as he lays out the case for the destructive intent and impact of the modernist approach to the Bible, particularly the Gospels. At times, however, he would have better served the topic by tackling some of the more obvious objections that could be made to some of his statements. (One minor one has to do with his theory - that he admits he isn't confident of - that John held some antogonistic views of Peter. As he argues this he doesn't contend with the significant Petrology that exists in John's Gospel, but rather confining himself to the passages where Peter is often interpreted in a negative light.) In other places I would have preferred if he "connected the dots" a bit more in showing how things like Spinoza's treatise on biblical interpretation actually fathered the modernist approach to the Bible. I respect his ultimate position regarding the order of the Synoptics - Matthew, Luke, then Mark - but I am partial to the more "traditional Augustinian" solution. I would have liked if he had spent more time grappling with the better modern apologies for that solution rather than blasting some of the more myopic gospel harmonies and generally regulating most of the modern defenses of the traditional solution to the heap of Fundamentalism. Still, all in all, I learned a good deal from his generally thorough work and would recommend it, with some reservation, to the student who has concerns about the modernist critique of the Bible and who is intereseted in enhancing his understanding of the history of the synoptic problem, particularly the contemporary situation.

Excellent work due to a unique approach........1999-10-16

I'm not a Bible Scholar, but I am a very well read minister. I must confess that, having read many books on this subject, I saw things in Dungan's book I'd never seen or heard of anywhere else. I sat and read it in a bookstore for hours before I bought it. I don't agree with it 100% -- but he sure does give a feast for thought.

A history of the synoptic problem: the canon, the text, the composition, and the interpretation of the Gospels.

Average customer rating:

A history of the synoptic problem: the canon, the text, the composition, and the interpretation of the Gospels.
David Laird Dungan
Manufacturer: New York, Doubleday, [
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Hardcover
ASIN: B000Q03WZE

Books:

Books Index

Books Home

Recommended Books