Creative Techniques For Stained Glass
Average customer rating: 5 out of 5 stars
  • Creative Techniques For Stained Glass
  • Brilliantly Creative, Clear and Concise
  • Interesting and Fun!
  • Great Intermediate Ideas
Creative Techniques For Stained Glass
Cliff Kennedy , and Jane Wendling Pompilio
Manufacturer: North Light Books
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback

GeneralGeneral | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
Glass & GlasswareGlass & Glassware | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
Similar Items:
  1. Basic Stained Glass Making: All the Skills and Tools You Need to Get Started (Stackpole Basics) Basic Stained Glass Making: All the Skills and Tools You Need to Get Started (Stackpole Basics)
  2. The Stained Glass Garden: Projects & Patterns The Stained Glass Garden: Projects & Patterns
  3. Modern Designs Stained Glass Pattern Book Modern Designs Stained Glass Pattern Book
  4. Creative Stained Glass: Modern Designs & Simple Techniques Creative Stained Glass: Modern Designs & Simple Techniques
  5. 390 Traditional Stained Glass Designs (Dover Pictorial Archive Series) 390 Traditional Stained Glass Designs (Dover Pictorial Archive Series)

ASIN: 1581806043

Book Description

Cliff Kennedy and Jane Wendling Pompilio combine stained glass techniques with the latest trends in bead, wire and metal crafting to bring readers never-before-seen projects! Creative Techniques for Stained Glass displays a range of styles, from traditional to contemporary, that offers something for everyone. This book:

* Provides templates that make the projects easy to do. Crafters can also use the authors' tips to design their own creations.

* Covers both copper foil techniques and the authors' innovative approach with random shapes and exposed spaces--readers can use either technique, or mix and match to craft something totally new.

* Has instructions for every project under the sun, including light switches, lamps, window panels, suncatchers and purses.

With projects in a range of skill levels, readers can choose just how easy-or challenging--they want to make their crafting experiences!

Customer Reviews:

4 out of 5 stars Creative Techniques For Stained Glass.......2007-07-06

Good book mainly for those that are looking for creative projects in 3D.
Very good pictures.

5 out of 5 stars Brilliantly Creative, Clear and Concise.......2006-07-10

I have tried stained glass with several different instructors, but without a lot of success. The instructors had their own technique and were busy with a lot of students. This terrific book shows you the way and not only with words but with the pictures and all the steps needed. Obviously the authors are experienced teachers, creative and educated in their art.

I highly recommend this book to anyone from beginners to advanced. You will want to keep it for learning and reference. The book gives education on everything you would need to know about stained glass. Wish my previous instructors had read this book. Enjoy!

5 out of 5 stars Interesting and Fun!.......2006-02-04

If you want to venture outside the realm of traditional stained glass creations, this book is for you! There are several projects in this book that take minor steps away from the traditional techniques and far more that go beyond. It was fun from start to finish...a must have for any stained glass library!

5 out of 5 stars Great Intermediate Ideas.......2005-09-21

This was full of interesting, out-of-the-ordinary, ideas.
There are far better books out there if you are a rank beginner, but if you have started to master some of the beginning techniques and are looking to expand your "repertoire" this is the book. It has some really creative ideas for projects that are beyond the basics but don't require expertise either.
The directions are detailed and easy to follow with plenty of full-color photos.
Creative Stained Glass: Modern Designs & Simple Techniques
Average customer rating: 5 out of 5 stars
  • Chock full of useful techniques
Creative Stained Glass: Modern Designs & Simple Techniques
Christine Stevenson
Manufacturer: Lark Books
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback

GeneralGeneral | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
Glass & GlasswareGlass & Glassware | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
Similar Items:
  1. Modern Designs Stained Glass Pattern Book Modern Designs Stained Glass Pattern Book
  2. The Stained Glass Garden: Projects & Patterns The Stained Glass Garden: Projects & Patterns
  3. Creative Techniques For Stained Glass Creative Techniques For Stained Glass
  4. The Stained Glass Handbook: Techniques for the Experienced or Budding Stained Glass Artist (Artist's Handbook Series) The Stained Glass Handbook: Techniques for the Experienced or Budding Stained Glass Artist (Artist's Handbook Series)
  5. Basic Stained Glass Making: All the Skills and Tools You Need to Get Started (Stackpole Basics) Basic Stained Glass Making: All the Skills and Tools You Need to Get Started (Stackpole Basics)

ASIN: 1600591329

Book Description

From in-a-weekend pieces to intricate designs that take more time, these 27 stained-glass projects shine with light, color, and texture, thanks to the great new glasses on the market today. More than 70 color photos present the techniques, all worked with easy-to-acquire, modern, and efficient tools. Try two methods of cutting, with or without making a pattern. Use overlays, plating, and patinas to color the finish, creatively combine different techniques, and see how to work with brass and copper came. Beginners can start on small glass panels and build the skills to make a flat fan lamp, a mirror suitable for the wall or in a window, and more.

Customer Reviews:

5 out of 5 stars Chock full of useful techniques.......2005-11-03

After I began taking a stained glass class, I ran to the library and the bookstore. My instructor is good, but he's only one opinion. I must have looked at a dozen books, but this is one of the two that I brought home. I'm certainly glad I did.

Like many such books, there are three sections: basic techiques, projects, and a gallery that shows what you can do (but offers no instruction -- just an ooh-ahh opportunity).

The techniques section is among the best I've encountered. In a sense, the info that beginners need is all about the same: the supplies you need, the types of glass available, etc. However, Creative Stained Glass always seems to have just a little more info that do the other books... maybe it's just four paragraphs about the kinds of solder instead of two, but at this point you need all the info you can get.

That first section is 40 pages, which is more than most books devote to the basics. The writing is friendly, too.

In addition, the projects are pretty! I've seen far too many stained glass books in which half the projects are, well, lame. The glass equivalent of a crying clown painted on velvet. The projects are more likely to be leaded rather than to use copper foil; most beginner books seem to choose copper. Each project has about three pages of instruction, plus the patter; my one quibble is that it often doesn't tell you by how much to enlarge the pattern.

I'm not positive I could have learned stained glass wholly from this or any book (this is one area in which a hands-on class makes all the difference), but this one would have given me the most confidence.

Overall, I've gotten the best advice from this book. I'm glad it's in my library. You should probably grab a copy, too.
Creative Glass Techniques: Fusing, Painting, Lampwork
Average customer rating: 4 out of 5 stars
  • Inspiring and delightful
  • Great fusing book
  • Good fusing book!
  • Encouraging start up
  • Pretty but shallow
Creative Glass Techniques: Fusing, Painting, Lampwork
Bettina Eberle
Manufacturer: Lark Books
ProductGroup: Book
Binding: Paperback

GeneralGeneral | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
Glass & GlasswareGlass & Glassware | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
Similar Items:
  1. Warm Glass: A Complete Guide to Kiln-Forming Techniques: Fusing, Slumping, Casting Warm Glass: A Complete Guide to Kiln-Forming Techniques: Fusing, Slumping, Casting
  2. Introduction to Glass Fusing Introduction to Glass Fusing
  3. Fused Glass Handbook Fused Glass Handbook
  4. Fuse It: A Continuing Journey in Kiln Worked Glass Fuse It: A Continuing Journey in Kiln Worked Glass
  5. Contemporary Warm Glass: A Guide to Fusing, Slumping & Kiln-Forming Techniques Contemporary Warm Glass: A Guide to Fusing, Slumping & Kiln-Forming Techniques

ASIN: 1579907644

Customer Reviews:

4 out of 5 stars Inspiring and delightful.......2007-09-08

I have to admit that, despite a few flaws, this remains one of my favorite books on making your own glass. Ms. Eberle has written a book that gets my creative juices flowing every time I read it. Her approach to creating functional/decorative glass is (or was at the time) unique, and I especially appreciate her use of mass-produced glassware to create some really beautiful things. It's well-illustrated.

That said, there are some frustrating aspects to this book. She doesn't really explain where to find some of the materials she uses, such as her "paints" and "crystal ice." While I can guess at their identity I can't be quite sure. I've also tried to locate the author (and in fact have sent several e-mails to what I *think* is the correct address) with no luck. She does describe the mechanics of full-fuse firing, but you'll need a pretty good understanding of firing schedules to fill in the blanks.

Even with the frustrations, though, this book is well worth the purchase price. I would love to see more from this author!

5 out of 5 stars Great fusing book.......2007-04-27

I have been fusing for 3 years now. I started with this book and still look back and get good ideas. You evolve and still can get something on a different level. Buy it.

5 out of 5 stars Good fusing book!.......2007-01-04

Great pictures. Lots of projects. Good adition to any fusing book collection.

4 out of 5 stars Encouraging start up.......2002-04-18

With no experience in glass work, this book is very encouraging for the beginner. Exercises are simple and clear to understand.
But I find the content of the projects very kitch, especially the finished works in the painting on glass section. I would have preferred if the creative quality be of far greater substance.
I am comming from an art/design profession, so the designs are not inspiring to me at all. Its approach may be too sunday hobbiest for practicing artists/designers.

3 out of 5 stars Pretty but shallow.......2002-01-18

I bought this book based on reviews from this page. I agree that the projects are beautiful and the artist very talented. The book is not really a "how to" in my opinion as it gives very sketchy technical information on all three glass techniques. I would not feel comfortable investing in an expensive kiln and supplies or attempting these projects without reading a far more thorough treatment of the subject first. It is very inspirational to look at: pretty but shallow.
Creative Glass Painting
Average customer rating: Not rated
    Creative Glass Painting
    Moira Neal
    Manufacturer: David & Charles Publishers
    ProductGroup: Book
    Binding: Paperback

    GeneralGeneral | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
    Glass & GlasswareGlass & Glassware | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
    GeneralGeneral | Arts & Photography | Subjects | Books
    Similar Items:
    1. Simple Glass Painting Simple Glass Painting
    2. Painting on Glass Painting on Glass
    3. Glass Painting: The Big Book of Patterns Glass Painting: The Big Book of Patterns
    4. Art Nouveau Glass Painting Made Easy Art Nouveau Glass Painting Made Easy
    5. Quick & Easy Glass Painting Quick & Easy Glass Painting

    ASIN: 0715312677

    Book Description

    Combining traditional and contemporary glass painting ideas, this collection of 20 step-by-step projects will enthuse beginners and the more advanced alike. Techniques such as stamping, sponging, stenciling, etching and marbling combine with gels, leadwork, paints, pens, outliners and much more. Comprehensive advice on every aspect of the craft ensures stunning results every time.
    Creative Studio Glass Painting with Other (Creative Studios) (Creative Studios)
    Average customer rating: Not rated
      Creative Studio Glass Painting with Other (Creative Studios) (Creative Studios)
      Top That Editors
      Manufacturer: Top That! Kids
      ProductGroup: Book
      Binding: Hardcover
      ASIN: 1845102487
      Creative Glass Crafts: Painting * Etching * Stained Glass & More
      Average customer rating: Not rated
        Creative Glass Crafts: Painting * Etching * Stained Glass & More
        Marthe Le Van
        Manufacturer: Lark Books
        ProductGroup: Book
        Binding: Paperback

        GeneralGeneral | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
        Glass & GlasswareGlass & Glassware | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
        Pottery & CeramicsPottery & Ceramics | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
        CeramicsCeramics | Other Media | Arts & Photography | Subjects | Books
        ASIN: 1579904300

        Book Description

        Glass crafting can offer perfect projects for the beginner: each of these is small in size, with a limited number of pieces, and uncomplicated to assemble. The projects reflect a variety of styles, too, from luscious florals to Eastern minimalism, and unconventional ways of working with glass (such as decoupage, beading, and bottle cutting).
        Stained Glass Painting: Basic Techniques of the Craft (Chilton's creative crafts series)
        Average customer rating: 5 out of 5 stars
        • A Solid Guide to "Real" Stained Glass Painting
        Stained Glass Painting: Basic Techniques of the Craft (Chilton's creative crafts series)
        Anita Isenberg
        Manufacturer: Chilton Book Co
        ProductGroup: Book
        Binding: Hardcover

        GeneralGeneral | Design & Decorative Arts | Arts & Photography | Subjects | Books
        GeneralGeneral | Arts & Photography | Subjects | Books
        ASIN: 0801966507

        Customer Reviews:

        5 out of 5 stars A Solid Guide to "Real" Stained Glass Painting.......2005-12-07

        The Isenbergs provide the writing; Master Glass Painter Dick Millard provides the skills and experience. The result is a solid introduction to the tools, techniques, and materials for "real" stained glass painting.
        Creative Stained Glass: Techniques for Unfired and Fired Projects.
        Average customer rating: Not rated
          Creative Stained Glass: Techniques for Unfired and Fired Projects.
          Polly. Rothenberg
          Manufacturer: Crown Publishing Group
          ProductGroup: Book
          Binding: Hardcover
          ASIN: 0517505819
          Creative China Painting
          Average customer rating: 2.5 out of 5 stars
          • Okay
          • An inspiring book full with different techniques and styles
          Creative China Painting
          Wanda Sutton
          Manufacturer: Search Press(UK)
          ProductGroup: Book
          Binding: Paperback

          GeneralGeneral | Instructional & How-To | Arts & Photography | Subjects | Books
          GeneralGeneral | Painting | Arts & Photography | Subjects | Books
          GeneralGeneral | Arts & Photography | Subjects | Books
          CeramicsCeramics | Other Media | Arts & Photography | Subjects | Books
          GeneralGeneral | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
          PaintingPainting | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
          Pottery & CeramicsPottery & Ceramics | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
          ASIN: 0855328134

          Customer Reviews:

          1 out of 5 stars Okay.......1999-09-18

          Whoever wrote the rave review must have been a good, faithful friend

          4 out of 5 stars An inspiring book full with different techniques and styles.......1998-08-26

          I found this book a must have on my china painting bookshelf. It has a load of technical instructions to compliment the veriety of methods used from standard, relief, lustres, glass and others mixed with to create different finishes. This book is for creative painters ready to explore some of the possibilities introduced bu it.
          Creative Glass Painting: 20 Projects for Creating Beautiful Glass
          Average customer rating: Not rated
            Creative Glass Painting: 20 Projects for Creating Beautiful Glass
            Moira Neal
            Manufacturer: David & Charles Publishers
            ProductGroup: Book
            Binding: Paperback

            DecoratingDecorating | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
            GeneralGeneral | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
            Glass & GlasswareGlass & Glassware | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
            PaintingPainting | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
            Pottery & CeramicsPottery & Ceramics | Crafts & Hobbies | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
            Painting & WallpaperingPainting & Wallpapering | Interior Design | Home & Garden | Subjects | Books
            ASIN: 071531212X

            Veil: Modesty, Privacy and Resistance (Dress, Body, Culture)
            Average customer rating: 4 out of 5 stars
            • Veil: A Study of Arabic Linguistics rather than Traditional Head Coverings
            • An excellent anthropological work
            • UNCOVERING THE MYSTIQUE OF THE VEIL
            • A Breakthrough Work!
            • A very disappointing and inaccurate treatment of an important topic
            Veil: Modesty, Privacy and Resistance (Dress, Body, Culture)
            Fadwa El Guindi
            Manufacturer: Berg Publishers
            ProductGroup: Book
            Binding: Paperback

            Textile & CostumeTextile & Costume | Design & Decorative Arts | Arts & Photography | Subjects | Books
            GeneralGeneral | Fashion | Arts & Photography | Subjects | Books
            GeneralGeneral | Anthropology | Social Sciences | Nonfiction | Subjects | Books
            Customs & TraditionsCustoms & Traditions | Social Sciences | Nonfiction | Subjects | Books
            GeneralGeneral | Gender Studies | Social Sciences | Nonfiction | Subjects | Books
            GeneralGeneral | Sociology | Social Sciences | Nonfiction | Subjects | Books
            GeneralGeneral | Women's Studies | Nonfiction | Subjects | Books
            GeneralGeneral | Islam | Religion & Spirituality | Subjects | Books
            Similar Items:
            1. The Veil Unveiled: The Hijab in Modern Culture The Veil Unveiled: The Hijab in Modern Culture
            2. Women and Gender in Islam: Historical Roots of a Modern Debate Women and Gender in Islam: Historical Roots of a Modern Debate
            3. Colonial Citizens Colonial Citizens
            4. Islam, Gender, and Social Change Islam, Gender, and Social Change
            5. Nurturing the Nation: The Family Politics of Modernizing, Colonizing, and Liberating Egypt, 1805-1923 Nurturing the Nation: The Family Politics of Modernizing, Colonizing, and Liberating Egypt, 1805-1923

            ASIN: 1859739296

            Book Description

            Shortlisted for the Katharine Briggs Folklore Award 2000.In the 1970s, often to the consternation of parents and siblings, certain progressive young Arab women voluntarily donned the veil. The movement, which rapidly expanded and continues to gather momentum, has sparked controversy within Islamic culture, as well as reactions ranging from perplexity to outrage from those outside it. Western feminist commentators have been particularly vociferous in decrying the veil, which they glibly interpret as a concrete manifestation of patriarchal oppression.However, most Western observers fail to realize that veiling, which has a long and complex history, has been embraced by many Arab women as both an affirmation of cultural identity and a strident feminist statement. Not only does the veil de-marginalize women in society, but it also represents an expression of liberation from colonial legacies. In short, contemporary veiling is more often than not about resistance. By voluntarily removing themselves from the male gaze, these women assert their allegiance to a rich and varied tradition, and at the same time preserve their sexual identity. Beyond this, however, the veil also communicates exclusivity of rank and nuances in social status and social relations that provide telling insights into how Arab culture is constituted. Further, as the author clearly demonstrates, veiling is intimately connected with notions of the self, the body and community, as well as with the cultural construction of identity, privacy and space.This provocative book draws on extensive original fieldwork, anthropology, history and original Islamic sources to challenge the simplistic assumption that veiling is largely about modesty and seclusion, honor and shame.

            Customer Reviews:

            1 out of 5 stars Veil: A Study of Arabic Linguistics rather than Traditional Head Coverings.......2006-11-03

            Fadwa El Guindi's work on the practice of veiling in Islam seems more like an in depth study of Arabic etymology than a comprehensive overview of the practice of veiling. El Guindi's book promises to chronicle the use of the veil while simultaneously dispelling "Western" myths about the practice of and ideology behind veiling. Unfortunately, her work relies too heavily on citations and becomes bogged down in trying to refute all other scholarly theories about veiling; her message gets lost somewhere between the tenth and twentieth assertion that past ethnographic studies of Islamic women and veiling are Euro- and ethnocentric. Although her idea of studying purely the practice of veiling by means of an ethnographic as well as textual approach has a great deal of merit in its own right, the implementation is poor and the actual writing poorer.

            Guindi's overreaching purpose is twofold: to dispel the common, "Westernized" myths put forth by trained anthropologists, and to use a textual and ethnography-based approach to understand more holistically the practice, implications, and purposes of veiling in modern, early Islamic, and, to some extent, pre-Islamic times. Her premise is that all previous studies of the veil have been about women and not the veil per se, and her argument is that the veil is actually a source of power and in some cases a legitimization of partial female autonomy rather than one of seclusion and male-enforced oppression.

            The first section of the book deals primarily with Guindi's claim that Women's and Islamic Studies scholars are ethnocentric in their interpretation of veiling which Guindi attempts to support by exhaustively citing works on the subject of veiling and haram. She then proceeds to explain why nearly all of these scholarly theories are incomplete, biased, or both. Though Chapter 2 touches on the historical and pre-Islamic roots of veiling, the first 45 pages of Veil are dominated by a theory-heavy argument about bias. It is here that Guindi presents her method of studying the veil which she believes to be a more holistic, culturally and historically-minded approach. In a fresh, novel way, Guindi argues that anthropologists must consult textual sources as well as historical and ethnographic data in order to understand cultural issues, especially those that garner a great deal of emotional fervor, such as the practice of veiling. As such, the first quarter of the book is more a work of anthropological theory than a study or history of veiling practices.
            Guindi attempts to resolve this lack of actual discussion about the veil in Section 2. The primary basis for her argument in this section is the implicit premise that if a society has not created a word for a certain idea, then the idea does not, in fact, exist within the culture. A prime example of this is the concept of "privacy," or at least some sort of Westernized notion of "privacy." Guindi argues that since there is no actual Arabic term for the concept of "privacy," then it must necessarily not exist within Arabic culture. This form of argument is the most prevalent throughout Section 2, and leads one to believe that one is reading a piece on Arabic etymology rather than a treatise on women's dress in Islamic culture.

            However, Guindi does provide an interesting, though long-winded, history of the anthropological notion of dress, which gives illumination to the position from which she writes. It would seem natural that Guindi, having finally made clear her holistic approach to anthropology and having given a brief history of the anthropology of dress, would then proceed to the practice of veiling, which seems to be the subject of her book. Instead, one finds an entire chapter on the etymology of the Arabic root h-r-m. Nevertheless, by page 97, Guindi begins her argument about the role of veiling in not only women's but also men's social spheres. She argues that veiling initially indicated social class, provided a means for moving in and out of the holy states in the daily life of a Muslim, and established a definite social space for women and men alike, especially men of the Rashayda ethnicity.

            Guindi then moves to describing men's forms of veiling to in a way that is defensive of and apologetic for both men's and women's forms of veiling. Her focus on Berber and Rashayda men's veiling practices are an attempt to further her argument that wearing the veil is empowering and not oppressive or imposed. Her concrete examples for this assertion range from Muslim women in India "beating" their husbands with their veils in a ritual every year to women in Bahrain attaching keys to their headdresses. In Guindi's argument, the example of women "beating" their husbands with their veils is significant because now the same women use sticks rather than veils to ritually "beat" their husbands, and Guindi thus equates the veil with beating stick. Similarly, Guindi argues that the attachment of keys to headdresses in Bahrain is symbolic because the veil is supposed to represent oppression while the keys, which represent freedom and autonomy, are attached to the symbols of women's oppression.

            The next topic the book discusses is how the veil came to symbolize modesty and piety, especially when freely donned by college students in Egypt. Guindi argues that voluntary veiling and minimal public interaction between males and veiled females shows the power and prestige of the veil, especially when its wearer is modern and integrated into society. This Islamic, college-based movement is claimed to be the reason for an overall increase in Islamic, modest dress in Egypt after the 1970's, and thus Guindi champions the covering of women as a means of increasing women's power. Furthermore, she cites the Iranian revolution that followed the mandate that no women should wear the chador as an example of the symbolic investment of the Islamic moral code in the veil itself. This public desire to wear the veil, especially among women, is one of the main points of Guindi's contention that the veil is not oppressive, inherently evil, or imposed in any place, but rather is valued by both men and women for its ability to confer protection, modesty, and the preservation of the family reputation.

            Although examples, such as the Iranian Revolution, are present in the book, it seems that this is more a work about anthropological method and Arabic linguistics than it is a comprehensive review of veiling practices in Islamic culture. This criticism is supported by Guindi's spending an entire chapter on the etymology of the Arabic root h-r-m. Furthermore, the fact that she quotes other authors more than she presents her own interpretation, especially when discussing anthropological theory, gives the impression that the title of the book is a misnomer. Instead, the title An Anthropological View of Arabic Veiling Etymology seems more fitting than Veil: Modesty, Privacy and Resistance. Indeed, Guindi becomes bogged down in presenting a theory-heavy point of view and spends far too few pages discussing the actual implications of and drives to veil. Despite Guindi's methodological merit of presenting a non-ethnocentric picture of modern veiling, she fails to provide a comprehensive study. She seems to oppose any sort of Western theory about the veil as false merely because it is Western and not because of its ethnographic or scholarly flaws. In this sense, Guindi seems to beg the question of a purely ethnocentric point of view in all modern scholarship on the veil but does little to actually refute the arguments of such culturally positioned scholars.

            Furthermore, Guindi's evidence in favor of her own point of view, especially the reinstitution of the veil in Iranian Revolution, seems to not-so-deftly ignore the effects of forced veiling on women who oppose donning the veil. While championing Iranian women for reasserting their culture and using the veil in a positive manner, Guindi avoids discussing the cultural and even psychological effects of a forcibly imposed chador on women who dislike or oppose the idea of the veil. This is perhaps the largest gap in Guindi's argument, especially when she seems to casually dismiss the imposition of chador in Iran as universally accepted in Iranian culture with no significant opposition. Furthermore, Guindi dismisses "the hysterics in the Western media about women in Afghanistan" as culturally positioned (185). Yet there comes a point when the issue is no longer about "Western" indignation about the treatment of women, but rather about human indignation about the subjugation of humans. This forced veiling also occurs in Saudi Arabia and such a widespread practice cannot merely be ignored away.

            On a more aesthetic note, the writing in the book itself does not readily lend itself to being read. The convoluted nature of the theory-heavy, anthropological language and the prolific use of Arabic words and phrases would leave many language purists balking. Furthermore, the organization of the text is not only difficult to understand, but also quite choppy, jumping from one seemingly unrelated topic to another. This makes for a difficult time trying identify Guindi's argument and also frustrates anyone trying to read the book in a substantive way. Describing the organizing scheme as "topical" seems to be generous. Indeed, jumping from the history of veiling to the current ethnocentric bias in anthropological research can hardly be described as organized or planned in any way.

            Although Guindi's holistic anthropological method possesses great potential, the actual book she has produced is politically correct ad nauseum, and generally convoluted in both argument and syntax. Guindi's purpose of providing a comprehensive study of veiling becomes doomed in quicksand-like language and tedious anthropological theory. Her unequivocal championing of the veil is more biased than that of her "ethnocentric" colleagues, and, in this bias, Guindi commits the crime that she preaches against for the entire first section of the book.
            Finally, Guindi's failure to address the situation of women who are forced to veil against their will seriously undermines argument. Given the promise of Guindi's method, the study she produced is disappointing. This reviewer hopes that Guindi's future efforts will produce lucid, insightful works that reflect their anthropological worth.

            5 out of 5 stars An excellent anthropological work.......2006-07-02

            This refreshing book presents the concept of veiling without falling in the stereotyping that it usually carries with it. The work seems very precise and impartial as well as conformant with academic anthropological practice. Unique in its genre, one cannot imagine an anthopology student specializing in the arabic or islamic society not reading it. The inside look of the author, as well as her scientific outlook, is pervasive throughout the book. The most important aspect to notice is the non-ethnocentric nature of the work, unlike many other books on the subject, as well as a shrewed analysis of the interplay of religion, social structure, local customs and historical evolution in arab women's dress. The bibliography is also extensive and points toward other interesting works, and many of the inline references are gems in themselves (for example the description of the veiling of the Kaabah ceremony is rather unknown and worth reading). The illustrations and photographs are very helpful in showing the diversity of anthropological concepts related to veiling and its various functions (proxemics, social status, religious statement, etc...). Definitely an excellent read unmatched so far in the subject matter it covers.

            5 out of 5 stars UNCOVERING THE MYSTIQUE OF THE VEIL.......2006-04-20

            In this extensively researched book, Fadwa El Guindi offers new insight into Middle Eastern women's decision to adopt modest Muslim attire since the 1970s.

            The author presents historical and anthropological documentation of the phenomena of covering up -- which she explains is not solely practiced by women.

            The reader gains a perspective of how the veil has been used from prehistory as a form of privacy, protection and class status. El Guindi stresses there is no fast rule on who wears or does not wear the veil. She also rejects radical Western feminists' claims that the veil degrades women. Rather, she stresses, the veil is a woman's silent defiance against imported Western culture and colonialism as in Algeria and Palestine and unpopular regimes in much of the Arab world.

            5 out of 5 stars A Breakthrough Work!.......2006-04-16

            Unfortunately, we Americans have been taught a view of Arab and Muslim cultures that are slanted by power politics, religious parochialism, and petrodollars.

            In this definitive work, Dr. El Guindi presents the historic, religious, and cultural foundations for veiling clearly and succinctly. The best work on this subject, Dr. El Guindi has removed the layers of distortion and misconception in a way that is easily understandable to Westerners.

            This fascinating and highly readable work is a must for any serious student of Middle-Eastern cultures. It is also a very important tool for anyone who seeks a better understanding of our rapidly shrinking global community.

            I'd give this work more than five stars, if I could.

            Kari Sprowl, M.A.

            2 out of 5 stars A very disappointing and inaccurate treatment of an important topic.......2005-12-14

            Fawda El Guindi's Veil: Modesty, Privacy and Resistance is a treatise on a fascinating and oft-misunderstood topic, that of veiling in Middle Eastern society. Yet it is a seriously flawed work, containing both historical inaccuracies and overt political undertones, which undermine El Guindi's theorizing on her topic.

            Due to her at times needlessly obtuse style, the main themes of "Veil..." are often subsumed underneath rhetoric. Simply, El Guindi's ethnographic work amongst Egyptian students in the early 1970s and 1980s had put her in an ideal situation to watch the formation of the student movement known as mitdayyinin, "the state of being religious". Influenced by the perceived victory of Egyptian forces in the October/Ramadan War of 1973 (1), some students began to reject the Western-style dress that had been popularized by modernizing states (Turkey and Egypt, especially). The mitydayyinin emphasized dressing in an 'Islamic' manner, a way of dress that has spread throughout the Muslim world and is often called 'ethnic Muslim' dress , despite it only being some 31 years old. That the mitdayyinin's use of veiling and modesty, something which is seen in most discourse as disempowering, actually represented the opposite to the mitdayyinin, is the foundation of El Guindi's theory of veiling: that all former discourse on the subject, not being from an Arab point of view, is ethnocentric, disempowering, sexist, and racist (a fallacious point familiar to every scholar who has had to deconstruct Edward Said's seminal "Orientalism").

            One of the main weaknesses of Veil is its very structure. Rather than presenting a coherent argument, it reads instead like a cobbled-together collection of articles, with only cursory editing. Indeed, significant portions of Veil are taken verbatim from an article by El Guindi in Fashion Theory, 3:1, with nary a word changed. Whilst making use of previous work is a completely acceptable practice, El Guindi includes her own work in "Veil..."'s bibliography no less than thirty-three times, and uses erratic methods of citation (the current author noticed at least four). Although this can be seen as academic nitpicking, it does, in the current author's eye, reduce her academic credit. By being unwilling to go outside her own fieldwork for any evidence of true relevance (nearly all other sources are criticized as being "Western", part of the "Judeo-Christian program of proselytizing (3)", or "ethnocentric", whether written by people of Arabic decent or no), El Guindi is guilty of insular intellectual thought, rendering her ideas unassailable by outside criticism.

            So concerned is El Guindi with presenting the uniqueness of Muslim dress, that she often fails to mention obvious ethnographic or historic corollaries. For example, whilst she declares, quoting Hansen, that "autonomy, independence and authority can be seen...in Bahrain where 'each home is locked with a padlock...[and] each woman carried the key to her house tied to her headcloth'", there is no mention of the medieval woman's chatelain, a garment around the waist similar in function and ideology. In modern Bahrain, modesty and female power are concentrated in the hair and head covering, whilst in medieval Europe, it was centered on the waist. Despite their different forms, the ideological function and statements are the same: a 'good' woman carries the keys to home.

            Amongst other examples of Al Guindi's attempt at exclusive understanding is the statement that "[the] interweaving of space and time, as individuals move in and out during the course of the day between worldly and sacred spheres is distinctly, perhaps uniquely, Islamic". That this statement is contentious is obvious to anyone with even a cursory familiarity with either theology or the anthropology of religion, in that many disparate religious groups see each moment as being lived in the transitory moments 'twidst sacred and worldly time. Although the daily calls to prayer and the rakat that follow can be seen as unique to Islam, the interruption of daily affairs for moments of sacral importance can be especially observed in Orthodox Judaism, monastic Christianity, and the Brahmins of India, all of which share with Islam a concern for orthopraxy (4).

            In the end El Guindi's theoretical perspectives are undermined by her polemicizing. Although Veil contains some chapters of solid scholarship (including an, albeit brief, section on male veiling), El Guindi's blatant politicizing and unwillingness to accept outside theory render "Veil..." a much weaker book than it might have been. The current author finds El Guindi's statement that the concerns of human rights organizations over the health and safety of women "in Afghanistan as the Taliban are consolidating their power...[results from] [t]he hysterics in the Western media...feed[ing] from ethnocentrism and feed[ing] into a reaction of extremism" leaves him with a sinking feeling of anthropological unprofessionalism and a chilling denial of reality. Unfortunately, the definitive ethnographic work on the process of veiling has yet to be written.

            (1) El Guindi refers to the conflict in glowing terms, as if it "brought about victory over Israel in the name of Islam". In fact, as noted by J.L. Esposito, the conflict was a loss for Egypt, despite the defeat of Israel's famed Bar Lev line. What truly motivated the Arab world was the propaganda of then-President of Egypt Anwar Saddat. For details on the aftermath of the October War upon the ideology of the Muslim world, see John Esposito, "Islam: The Straight Path": 160.

            (2) Attesting to the power of their dress the mitdayyinin later came to be called Islamiyyin, a term which remains to this day. In addition, the women's dress has come to be known as al-ziyy al-Islami, "Islamic dress".

            (3) It is noteworthy that throughout the work, El Guindi ignores that Islam itself is a proselytizing religion.

            (4) El Guindi's reticence in mentioning any similarities between Islam, Judaism, and Christianity is an unfortunate thread running throughout the work.

            Books:

            1. Customer Data Integration: Reaching a Single Version of the Truth (SAS Institute Inc.)
            2. Dem Bones
            3. Dona Perfecta (El Libro De Bolsillo)
            4. Double Tap (Paul Madriani Novels)
            5. Edges of Empire: Orientalism and Visual Culture (New Interventions in Art History)
            6. Flint the King (Dragonlance: Preludes)
            7. Fortunata Y Jacinta (2 Volume Set)
            8. Freak Show: Presenting Human Oddities for Amusement and Profit
            9. From Russia with Tough Love: Pavel's Kettlebell Workout for a Femme Fatale
            10. Fuel-Injected Dreams: A Novel

            Books Index

            Books Home

            Recommended Books

            1. Distant Neighbors: A Portrait of the Mexicans
            2. Walk Two Moons
            3. The Hanged Man's Song
            4. The House of the Scorpion
            5. The Measure of a Man: A Spiritual Autobiography
            6. The Yaws' Handbook of Physical Properties for Hydrocarbons And Chemicals
            7. Theory of History in Ortega Y Gasset: "The Dawn of Historical Reason"
            8. Abstract Expressionist Women Painters
            9. Simon & Schuster's Guide to Reptiles and Amphibians of the World
            10. The Other War: Letters from a Gi in India in 1944 and 1945